USER COMMENTS ON RTV SLOVENIA
= A PUBLIC SPACE OF ABUSE
On the publicly funded MMC RTV Slovenia portal, propaganda, hate content, and disinformation are systematically disseminated. Following the example of the vast majority of public service media in the EU, we advocate for disabling the commenting function.
TABLE OF CONTENT
1. THE CORE PROBLEM
We entitled this website RTV Exposé after more than a year of continued activity in which we gathered sufficient data and evidence to critically assert the following: in our assessment, the existing system of accountability and moderation contributes to the spread of propagandistic, hateful, and otherwise harmful content in user comments (hereinafter referred to as “comments”).
Hate Content
MMC allows the spread of chauvinistic, homophobic, antisemitic, sexist, racist, inciting, and vulgar comments.
Inconsistent Moderation
Moderation is applied subjectively, while propaganda and hate content remain unchecked.
Pro-Russian Propaganda
The highest-rated comments on the war in Ukraine are openly pro-Russian and undermine Western institutions. Such propaganda is incompatible with the mission of a public service media outlet.
The commenting format on MMC RTV contributes to radicalisation and fails to encourage meaningful discussion, instead fostering emotional, polarised, and often hostile expressions of opinion. As will be shown below, we have conducted multiple analyses and international comparisons in our own time, gathered evidence, raised concerns, and repeatedly called on those responsible to engage in reflection, discussion, and change …
This website is the consequence and result of their persistent passivity. Because we care.
2. RTV SLOVENIA PRIORITISES COMMERCIAL INTERESTS OVER THE PUBLIC SPACE
PUBLIC SERVICE MEDIA AND THE PUBLIC INTEREST
A UNIQUE CASE IN THE EU
Only four other public broadcasters in the EU—Austria’s, Finland’s, France’s, and Luxembourg’s—allow user comments, and then only on a far more limited scale, under stricter rules and more careful moderation. Such comments as those presented below are not found on their websites.
RTV PROGRAMME STANDARDS (2024) AS ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT DOCUMENTS OF RTV SLOVENIA
A THREAT TO DEMOCRACY
The current commenting system leads to the spread of disinformation, a loss of trust in journalism, the radicalisation of society, social division, and the undermining of political decision-making.
Comment moderation has financial implications for the public broadcaster, as reflected in the statement below:
3. RTV SLOVENIA – UNIQUE CASE IN THE EU
ANALYSIS OF COMPARABLE PUBLIC MEDIA WEBSITES IN THE EU REGARDING COMMENTING
Among comparable public media in the European Union, MMC RTV Slovenia stands out as a unique case, as it is the only one to allow near-unrestricted commenting under almost all news articles. Due to understaffed moderation and the high volume of comments, the mass spread of hate speech, disinformation, and propaganda is tolerated—on a platform funded by the public.
Comparable public media in the EU that do NOT allow commenting:
- Belgium: Vlaamse Radio- en Televisieomroeporganisatie (VRT) www.vrt.be
- Belgium: Radio-télévision belge de la communauté française (RTBF) www.rtbf.be
- Bulgaria: Bulgarian National Television (BNT) www.bnt.bg
- Croatia: Hrvatska radiotelevizija (HRT) www.hrt.hr
- Cyprus Cyprus Broadcasting Corporation (CyBC) www.cybc.com.cy
- Czech Republic: Česká televize (ČT) ct24.ceskatelevize.cz
- Denmark: Danmarks Radio (DR) www.dr.dk
- Estonia: Eesti Rahvusringhääling (ERR) www.err.ee
- Germany: Arbeitsgemeinschaft der öffentlich-rechtlichen Rundfunkanstalten der Bundesrepublik Deutschland (ARD) www.ard.de
- Germany: Zweites Deutsches Fernsehen (ZDF) www.zdf.de
- Greece: Hellenic Broadcasting Corporation (ERT) www.ert.gr
- Hungary: MTVA www.mti.hu
- Ireland: Raidió Teilifís Éireann (RTÉ) www.rte.ie
- Italy: Radiotelevisione Italiana (RAI) www.rai.it
- Latvia: Latvijas Televīzija (LTV) www.lsm.lv
- Lithuania: Lietuvos nacionalinis radijas ir televizija (LRT) www.lrt.lt
- Malta: Public Broadcasting Services Ltd (PBS) www.tvmnews.mt
- The Netherlands: Nederlandse Omroep Sctichting (NOS) www.nos.nl
- Poland: Telewizja Polska Info (TVP Info) www.tvp.pl
- Portugal: Rádio e Televisão de Portugal (RTP) www.rtp.pt
- Romania: Societatea Română de Televiziune (TVR) www.tvrinfo.ro
- Slovakia: Rozhlas a televízia Slovenska (RTVS) www.spravy.stvr.sk
- Spain: Corporación Radiotelevisión Española (RTVE) www.rtve.es
- Sweden: Sveriges Television (SVT) www.svt.se
Comparable public media in the EU that allow commenting:
- Austria: (ORF) www.orf.at. A dedicated section (debatte.orf.at) with strict commenting rules; the number of ongoing debates is permanently limited to 11.
- Finland: (YLE) www.yle.fi. Commenting is enabled only under selected news items and only on the day of publication; all comments are pre-moderated, and commenting under news about the war in Ukraine is usually disabled.
- France: www.francetvinfo.fr. Although it has, alongside RTV Slovenia, one of the most permissive commenting systems, news about the war in Ukraine typically receive on average four times fewer comments than on MMC, and all published comments are often removed retroactively.
- Luxembourg: (RTL) www.rtl.lu. Commenting is enabled only under certain news items and rarely under foreign affairs coverage; all comments are automatically deleted after 18 days.
- Slovenia: – MMC (RTV) www.rtvslo.si. Commenting is enabled under almost all news items; only a few use pre-moderation, which, in turn, is usually ineffective. It is the only public broadcaster in the EU that increasingly allows commenting during nighttime hours in the absence of any moderation..
RTV Slovenia Leads by Far in the Number of Comments on Ukraine War Coverage
We conducted a quantitative analysis of comments on Ukraine-related news published by the above-listed public broadcasters during the period from 1 March to 20 April 2025. The analysis does not include Radio Television Luxembourg, as commenting on news articles about Ukraine is not enabled there.
A total of 13,633 comments were published under the analysed articles on MMC RTV Slovenia, 3,389 on FranceInfo, and 5,431 on Finland’s Yle.
Source: authors’ analysis.
A comparison of commenting activity on news about the war in Ukraine on RTV Slovenija, FranceInfo, and Finland’s Yle shows that the relative volume of commenting is by far the highest in Slovenia. When adjusted for population size, Slovenia records as many as 6.49 comments per 1,000 inhabitants, which is 129 times more than in France (0.05) and approximately seven times more than in Finland (0.97).
4. RTV SLOVENIJA AND ITS PROGRAMME STANDARDS
The Programme Standards are a foundational document of the public institution RTV Slovenia. They explicitly state: “Failure to comply with the Programme Standards constitutes a breach of employment obligations and grounds for disciplinary liability.”
The analysed cases indicate deviations from the Programme Standards of RTV Slovenia as defined in the applicable documents.
5. PROPAGANDA ON RTV SLOVENIJA
5.1 ANALYSIS OF COMMENTS UNDER NEWS ABOUT THE WAR IN UKRAINE ON RTV SLOVENIA
Between 3 January 2024 and 24 February 2024 (50 articles), and between 12 February 2025 and 12 May 2025 (100 articles), we systematically analysed comments posted under 150 MMC news articles about the war in Ukraine. The analysis focused on the 20 highest-rated comments (based on the number of stars/likes) under each article, as these are typically displayed as “recommended” on the first page of the comment section.
RESULT: As many as 91% of these comments (2,730 out of 3,000) are pro-Russian/anti-Western in orientation, and in 52 cases—representing more than one third of the articles—this share reaches 100%.
Source: authors’ analysis
The analysis clearly demonstrates that comments on MMC serve as a tool for disseminating pro-Russian propaganda and disinformation. Under news about the war in Ukraine, recurring patterns of established propagandistic narratives systematically emerge, receiving mass support through likes and thereby creating the false impression that they represent prevailing public opinion.
This therefore constitutes a deliberate amplification of propaganda on a publicly funded platform.
Show the details of the Analysis
5.2 COMMON NARRATIVE PATTERNS OF PRO-RUSSIAN COMMENTERS
The following shared narrative patterns were identified among pro-Russian and anti-Western commenters:
- relativisation or denial of Russian aggression through claims that the war was provoked by Ukraine and the West;
- criticism and delegitimisation of Zelensky as a “criminal” and a “NATO-installed dictator”;
- the portrayal of all Ukrainians as Nazis and as “murderous and corrupt successors of Bandera”;
- the deliberate spread of doubt about international institutions;
- claims that this is “a US war against Russia fought at Ukraine’s expense” and that “the West is manipulating Ukraine”;
- support for Trump (during his presidential campaign) and hostility toward the EU and Biden; frequent accusations of Western war-mongering;
- references to “censorship” and “Western propaganda”;
- emphasising the credibility of Russian versions of events, citing (pro-)Russian media, a high level of distrust in mainstream sources of information, and suspicion toward Western media (Reuters, The Guardian, The New York Times, RTV Slovenija);
- the glorification of Russian successes and the highlighting of Russian military victories;
- the glorification of Russia as a rational and peace-loving force;
- the minimisation of civilian casualties through references to collateral damage;
- the discourse is marked by “whataboutism” and deflections to other conflicts, as well as historical comparisons with the Second World War (“Germany against Russia again”);
- the use of sarcasm and coarse derogatory language targeting Ukrainian leaders, Russian dissidents, and EU officials (Zelensky is described as a “comedian,” “drug addict,” “Zelenko,” and a “Kyiv gnome”; Ursula von der Leyen as “Ursula von der Liar,” “von Pfizer,” and “Josef Mengele”; “Kaja KallaSS,” etc.);
- the glorification of Vladimir Putin and other autocratic or dictatorial leaders (Lukashenko, Kim Jong Un, etc.) as strong, competent, just, and rational;
Distinct characteristics of certain pro-Russian / anti-Western commenters:
- the total character count of an individual commenter’s contributions under a single article is nearly five times that of the article itself;
- other users thank them for “information that Western media conceal” and say that a portion of the RTV licence fee should be allocated to them;
- in response to reports of civilian casualties from Russian attacks, they share links to ballet and classical Russian music performances
- they praise “beautiful images of Moscow”;
- they comment exclusively on armed conflicts and/or polarising topics;
- under different news articles, they post dozens of identical comments (so-called propaganda spamming).
An overview of the applied taxonomy of pro-Russian narrative patterns.
This constitutes a form of hybrid threat that is deliberately planned and maliciously executed. Through various, often combined methods, the target—such as a state or an institution—is subjected to attempts at destabilisation. Hybrid tactics are becoming increasingly complex and sophisticated; they do not represent only a security risk, but also a threat to democracy, as they interfere with democratic processes (of which elections are an integral part).
Comments on MMC are not merely random opinions. They have become a channel for disseminating a hybrid threat in the form of propaganda that undermines democracy and the public interest. It must also be emphasised that, under news articles about the war in Ukraine, all comments are pre-moderated, meaning that they are reviewed and approved by a moderator prior to publication. The results of this moderation can be seen in the accompanying collage.
To explain why all articles on the war in Ukraine published on 24ur.com are closed to commenting, we contacted the editorial team. The response is reproduced below.
5.3 ANALYSIS: COMMENT LENGTH
The comments posted by certain user accounts are, in terms of volume, several times longer than the journalistic articles themselves. This level of disproportionality suggests a deliberate strategy to dominate the discussion space, which is characteristic of organised propaganda practices.
The chart above illustrates the ratio between the number of characters in ten journalistic articles about the war in Ukraine and the total number of characters in the comments posted by single user accounts under those articles. For each user, a different set of ten articles was selected in which this ratio is pronounced the most.
Source: authors’ own analyis. Data available here.
5.4 SUMMARY OF CARDIFF UNIVERSITY RESEARCH ON PRO-KREMLIN PROPAGANDA
In September 2021, researchers at Cardiff University published a report entitled ‘How a Kremlin-Linked Influence Operation is Systematically Manipulating Western Media to Construct & Communicate Disinformation – Part 1 – Detection Report‘.
They identified “pro-Russian trolling” as a central component of pro-Russian propaganda:
5.5 EXAMPLES OF COMMENTS ON RTV SLOVENIA CONTAINING PROPAGANDA
All comments posted under news articles about the war in Ukraine on RTV Slovenija’s website are pre-moderated. This means that a moderator reviews each comment before publication and approves it only if, in their judgement, it does not violate any of the rules. As such, the comments presented below are the clearest possible reflection of moderation practices on RTV Slovenija.
SHOW/HIDE COMMENTS
Source: rtvslo.si
1.b PROPAGANDNO SMETENJE – UPORABNIK HOR
Uporabnik je pod novicami oddal več kot 30 enakih komentarjev (vsi niso vključeni v kolaž) z enim samim citatom Jeffreya Sachsa – akademika s politično zelo kontroverznimi stališči, ki ponavlja narative Kremlja o krivdi ZDA za vojno v Ukrajini.
PRIKAŽI KOMENTARJE
Vir: rtvslo.si
1.b PROPAGANDNO SMETENJE – UPORABNIK Stane102
Uporabnik je oddal 10 enakih komentarjev, v katerih poveličuje Rusijo; 6 enakih komentarjev, v katerih za vojno v Ukrajini krivi EU in Zahod; 17 enakih komentarjev, v katerih trdi, da se je Evropa odločila postati drugorazredna kolonija ZDA; ter 3 enake komentarje s propagandno basnijo o “potrpežljivem medvedu” in “drezajočih šakalih”.
PRIKAŽI KOMENTARJE
Vir: rtvslo.si
RTV Slovenija je tudi edini javni medij v EU, ki omogoča profilne slike.
ANTI-EU:
Vir: rtvslo.si
DRUGAČE NEPRIMERNE:
Vir: rtvslo.si
5.6 ODZIVI ODGOVORNIH NA RTV SLOVENIJA GLEDE PROPAGANDE
O sumih, da gre za usklajeno delovanje posameznikov pri komentarjih s politično propagando, povezano z avtokratskimi režimi, so bili na RTV obveščeni že leta 2021. Kljub priporočilu tedanje Varuhinje Ilinke Todorovski, naj bo uredništvo posebej pozorno na propagando, je ta v komentarjih prisotna vedno bolj, ne manj.
S tem vprašanjem se je junija 2023 srečala tudi trenutna Varuhinja Marica Uršič Zupan. Uporabnica je menila, da proruski komentarji pod članki dobivajo nesorazmerno število zvezdic, zaradi prevelikih možnosti za zlorabe ter razširjenosti sovražnega govora in propagande pa je predlagala ukinitev komentiranja v slogu Siola.
Varuhinja se v odzivu ni niti z besedo dotaknila opozoril o propagandi, svoje mnenje o ukinitvi možnosti komentiranja je dobesedno prekopirala iz prejšnjih poročil, na koncu pa brez kakršnekoli utemeljitve navedla, da je Siol ukinil komentiranje iz drugih razlogov.
6. TEMATSKI SKLOPI (OSTALIH) NEPRIMERNIH KOMENTARJEV
6.1 POZIVANJE K NASILJU IN ZANIKANJE HOLOKAVSTA
V oči bode dejstvo, da je velik del teh komentarjev prestal predhodno moderacijo, ob njih pa se lahko upravičeno vprašamo, ali so moderatorji organom pregona prijavili katerikoli komentar z očitnimi znaki kaznivega dejanja.
PRIKAŽI KOMENTARJE
Vir: rtvslo.si
6.2 ŽALJIVI DO DRUŽBENIH SKUPIN
Gre za komentarje, ki so žaljivi, sovražni ali nestrpni do žensk, spolnih manjšin, pripadnikov drugih ras ali etničnih skupin itd.
PRIKAŽI KOMENTARJE
Vir: rtvslo.si
6.3 ŽALJIVI DO JAVNIH OSEBNOSTI
Najpogosteje so tarča najhujših žaljivk zahodne političarke in funkcionarke iz Slovenije in tujine. Sledijo jim moški kolegi, vojaške strokovnjakinje in strokovnjaki, akademiki, aktivisti ter druge javne osebnosti.
PRIKAŽI KOMENTARJE
Vir: rtvslo.si
6.4. ŽALJIVI DO DRUGIH UPORABNIKOV
Različne žaljivke dobro ponazarjajo raven razprave med komentatorji na RTV Slovenija in razkrivajo šibkosti sistema prijav, na katerega se moderatorji močno zanašajo. Če uporabniki ne prijavljajo niti žaljivk, ki so jih deležni sami, kako naj pričakujemo, da bodo dosledno prijavljali neprimerne komentarje, ki se nanje ne nanašajo neposredno?
PRIKAŽI KOMENTARJE
Vir: rtvslo.si
6.5 O RTV SLOVENIJA
Ena najpogostejših tarč zlonamernih komentarjev so novinarji in novinarke RTV Slovenija. Nekateri uporabniki jih omenjajo po imenih ali začetnicah, drugi žalijo celoten novinarski kolektiv ali novinarski ceh; pojavljajo se celo odkrite grožnje. RTV Slovenija je edini javni medij v EU, ki na svojih straneh omogoča platformo za blatenje lastne institucije in njenih zaposlenih, s čimer dodatno spodkopava zaupanje v sebe kot javni zavod.
PRIKAŽI KOMENTARJE
Vir: rtvslo.si
6.6 TEORIJE ZAROT
Na RTV Slovenija se pojavljajo teorije zarot, pogosto prežete z antisemitizmom: od trditev, da so Judi krivi za obe svetovni vojni in napade 11. septembra, do zanikanja avtentičnosti Dnevnika Ane Frank kot »fikcije« ter širjenja mitov o domnevnih globalnih elitah, ki naj bi si prizadevale za vzpostavitev ene svetovne vlade in depopulacijo.
PRIKAŽI KOMENTARJE
Vir: rtvslo.si
6.7 VULGARNI IN DRUGAČE NEPRIMERNI KOMENTARJI
Med neprimerne vsebine sodijo deljenje povezav do posnetkov usmrtitev, zapisi o pedofiliji in incestu, apokaliptično strašenje, nedovoljeno oglaševanje vedeževalskih ali drugih spletnih strani ter uporaba prostaškega jezika in grobih žaljivk.
PRIKAŽI KOMENTARJE
Vir: rtvslo.si
KOMENTIRANJE POD NOVICAMI V ČRNI KRONIKI
Ena od perečih tematik, na katero so v preteklosti sicer opozarjali že drugi, so komentarji pod novicami iz črne kronike. V poročilih Varuhinje lahko beremo odgovor iz leta 2023, kjer je vodja administratorjev pojasnil:
Opravili smo analizo člankov v črni kroniki in ugotavljali, ali se administratorji držijo zapisanega. Pri 323 novicah iz črne kronike (obdobje 1.6.-6.10.2025) je bilo komentiranje omogočeno pri 173 novicah, od tega 8 pri dogodkih s smrtnim izidom, 30 v zvezi z nasilnimi dejanji in 5 v zvezi s težkimi nesrečami. Pri teh 42 novicah je bilo skupno objavljenih 1.387 komentarjev.
Ob tem v oči zbode še dejstvo, da je pod 38 novicami še vedno možno oddati komentarje, kljub temu, da naj bi bilo komentiranje zaprto po 5 dneh od objave novice.
Navedenega ne moremo pripisati napakam ali enkratnim zdrsom, temveč zasledovanju večjega obiska, klikov in s tem podrejanja javnega medija tržnim interesom.
ZAVAJANJE O DOSTOPNOSTI STATISTIKE UMAKNJENIH KOMENTARJEV
RTV Slovenija že več let v poročilih Varuhinje in izjavah administratorjev ponavlja trditev, da je na portalu MMC RTV SLO umaknjenih manj kot odstotek komentarjev.
Isti posamezniki hkrati priznavajo, da nimajo dostopa do statistike umaknjenih komentarjev, na podlagi katere bi bilo takšno trditev sploh mogoče preveriti.
Če tega podatka nima niti uredništvo za nove medije, kot je leta 2025 izrecno zapisala odgovorna urednica, potem gre pri večletnem navajanju istega deleža za neutemeljeno in nepreverljivo trditev, ne za empirično ugotovitev.
Če administratorji nimajo vpogleda v statistiko objavljenih in umaknjenih komentarjev, potem ne morejo vedeti, ali je delež umikov res manjši od enega odstotka.
ŠE POMEMBNEJE: tudi če bi bil podatek o »manj kot 1 %« umaknjenih komentarjev točen, sam po sebi ne pove ničesar o tem, koliko objavljenih komentarjev je dejansko neprimernih. Delež umikov meri izključno število posegov, ne pa kakovosti ali problematičnosti vsebine, ki je na portalu ostala objavljena.
Sami smo prijavili na tisoče neprimernih komentarjev, ki so jih uporabniki oddali pred meseci ali leti in jih v nasprotnem nikoli ne bi odstranili. Kljub temu RTV Slovenija ta delež že več let uporablja kot osrednji argument v razpravah o komentiranju na MMC.
7. ODGOVORNOST NOSIJO …
Komentarje moderirajo moderatorji. Nad njimi bdi odgovorna urednica. Če tudi ta ne ukrepa, bi morala opozorila prepoznati varuhinja pravic gledalcev, poslušalcev, bralcev in uporabnikov RTV Slovenija, ki naj bi Upravi predlagala spremembe in rešitve, kadar pa tudi ta ne ukrepa, preide odgovornost na najvišji nadzorni organ – Svet RTV Slovenija.
Veriga odgovornosti je jasna: od administratorjev in uredništva do Varuhinje, Uprave in Sveta RTV. Kdor ne opravi svojega dela oz. nadzora, je soodgovoren za širjenje sovražnih vsebin in propagande na javnem mediju.
VARUHINJA PRAVIC GLEDALCEV IN POSLUŠALCEV
Varuhinja vztrajno zagovarja sedanjo ureditev komentiranja, saj naj bi bila ta “v skladu z duhom pluralne družbe“, pri čemer se neutemeljeno (kot smo pokazali tu) sklicuje na ustavno pravico do svobode govora.
Svoje stališče dodatno utemeljuje z irelevantnimi podatki, kot so rezultati spletne ankete (N=60) iz leta 2020, vse napake moderatorjev pa opravičuje z njihovo preobremenjenostjo in kadrovsko podhranjenostjo.
Njeni odgovori na številne pritožbe uporabnikov glede komentiranja in moderiranja kažejo na usklajeno delovanje z odgovorno urednico MMC. Obe namreč vztrajata pri obstoječem stanju in s tem po našem mnenju branita parcialne interese, ne pa interesov širše slovenske javnosti.
Varuhinja bi morala biti pri svojem delu samostojna in neodvisna. Vendar pa bi morale obstajati sistemske varovalke za primere, ko z neodzivnostjo in neustreznim delovanjem neposredno škoduje ugledu javnega medija – posledice za družbo kot celoto pa so lahko še bistveno širše.
Zbrani primeri, ki jih objavljamo spodaj, v resnici kažejo na njeno izrazito pristranskost ter nekritično povzemanje mnenj uredništva in/ali moderatorjev.
VARUHINJE NE ZANIMAJO OBREMENILNA DEJSTVA
V korespondenci z Varuhinjo smo opozorili na neprimerne komentarje pod novico “S Kinodvora strgali mavrično zastavo in jo zažgali. Policija išče najstnike”. Čeprav je novica objavljena v rubriki črna kronika in obravnava občutljivo tematiko, so se za predhodno moderacijo komentarjev odločili šele naknadno, neprimerni komentarji pa so bili kljub večkratni prijavi objavljeni ves konec tedna.
Ko smo predložili dokaze v obliki posnetkov zaslonov, smo prejeli dozo “gaslightanja” – sprva s strani administratorjev (“Nekaj neprimernih komentarjev se je izmuznilo in smo jih umaknili veliko prej, kot trdi gospod.”), nato pa še s strani Varuhinje.
Ko smo jo pozvali, da naj sledi dejstvom in zahteva izpis časa odstranitve komentarjev in vklopa predmoderacije, nas je zavrnila, saj je “ocenila, da s tem ne bi ugotovila ali rešila ničesar pomembnega”, v svojem odgovoru pa se je znova neutemeljeno(!) sklicevala na pravico do svobode izražanja.
Prikaži neprimerne komentarje
Na mladih svet stoji 🙂 Če bi mi kdo vsiljeval to LGBT sceno pred 20 leti, kot to počnejo sedaj, bi verjetno takrat s kolegi nardil enako ali pa se kaj bolj izvirnega. Mladi, a nikakor ne slepi
Nehajte že s temi zastavami, ker v ljudeh vzbujate vedno več nesoglasja z vami. Tudi heteroseksualci ne mahamo z nekimi zastavami, pa imamo veliko več zaslug za potomstvo človeškega rodu kakor vi.
Če so že zoprni kot driska, kdo jim pa pri nas kaj slabega hoče? Sami se s to maškarado podkrepljeno s provokacijo spravljajo v tak položaj.
VARUHINJA NORMALIZIRA SISTEMSKE POMANJKLJIVOSTI MODERIRANJA
Uredništvu smo prijavili več uporabnikov, ki so pod različnimi uporabniškimi imeni grobo kršili pravila. Standardi in pravila komentiranja na rtvslo.si v točki 19 izrecno določajo: “Uporabniku, ki je bil zaradi neupoštevanja pravil dodan pod nadzor ali blokiran, se onemogoči registracija novega uporabniškega imena. Registriranje več uporabniških imen z namenom nadaljnjega kršenja pravil ni dovoljeno.”
V enem primeru blokiranega uporabnika so se moderatorji strinjali, da “vsi indici res kažejo, da je uporabnik že imel registrirano uporabniško ime“, in ga dodali pod nadzor. Ob tem so prvič odkrito priznali, da zaradi tehničnih omejitev sistema ne morejo preprečiti novih registracij blokiranih uporabnikov, kar pomeni dejansko neizvajanje lastnih pravil.
Varuhinja se nam je sicer zahvalila za opozorilo, ni pa niti z besedo problematizirala tega priznanja tehnične nemožnosti izvajanja pravil.
Tak odziv pomeni spregled in normalizacijo sistemske napake. Odziv Varuhinje je bil zato neprimeren, nezadosten in institucionalno neustrezen.
5. ODGOVORNA UREDNICA MMC
ZAVAJANJE O KOMENTIRANJU V ODSOTNOSTI MODERATORJEV:
V korespondenci smo Varuhinji izpostavili, da je bilo pod novicami o Euru 2024 komentiranje omogočeno tudi po 22. uri v odsotnosti moderacije. Varuhinja nam je posredovala pojasnilo odgovorne urednice Ksenje Tratnik, da je “novinar po nesreči označil možnost komentiranja izven delovnega časa”.
Ko smo pojasnili, da smo že v izvirnem sporočilu priložili posnetke zaslonov 29 različnih novic z omogočenim nočnim komentiranjem, so na uredništvu nenadoma spremenili stališče in zapisali, da so “začeli junija uvajati spremembo glede komentiranja športnih novic”, saj “je na športni sekciji malo neprimernih komentarjev”.
RTV Slovenija tako kot edini javni medij v EU še naprej ohranja možnost nočnega komentiranja, kolaž s posnetki zaslonov pa dokazuje, da se je ta praksa začela že dolgo pred junijem 2024. Navedbe odgovorne urednice niso skladne z zbranimi primeri in dokumentiranimi posnetki zaslona.
Prikaži neprimerne komentarje
Vir: rtvslo.si
2. UPRAVA RTV SLOVENIJA
Uprava RTV Slovenija je za stanje na področju komentiranja neposredno soodgovorna tudi zato, ker sama določa programske in operativne cilje, ki jih morajo uredništva zasledovati. V veljavnem Programsko-produkcijskem načrtu za leto 2025 (in tudi za leto 2024) je kot ključni programski cilj Uredništva za nove medije izrecno navedeno »povečanje interakcije in sodelovanja uporabnikov«, operacionalizirano kot »ohranitev števila komentarjev«. Takšen cilj ima neposredne in predvidljive posledice: uredništvo je spodbujeno, da komentarje ohranja in povečuje njihovo količino, ne glede na kakovost, vsebino ali skladnost s Programskimi standardi.
Uredništva delujejo v okviru ciljev, ki jih postavi Uprava, in so odgovorna za njihovo uresničevanje. Če Uprava kot merilo uspešnosti določi količino komentarjev, hkrati pa ne zagotovi ustreznih kadrovskih, tehničnih in vsebinskih varovalk za preprečevanje sovražnega govora, dezinformacij in propagande, s tem ustvarja sistemski pritisk v smeri tržnih metrik, ki so v nasprotju z javnim poslanstvom RTV Slovenija.
Odgovornost za posledice takšne usmeritve zato ne more ostati omejena zgolj na raven moderatorjev ali uredništva, temveč sega do same Uprave, ki je te cilje določila in potrdila.
SVET RTV SLOVENIJA – organ nadzora
Ko smo po številnih neuspelih poskusih pritožb spoznali, da Varuhinja nekritično povzema stališča uredništva in administratorjev, smo na Svet RTV podali dve prijavi neukrepanja uredništva MMC pri moderaciji sovražnega govora in proruske propagande ter pobudi za preučitev politike komentiranja novic – prvo februarja 2025 in drugo maja 2025.
Svet RTV je našo pritožbo odstopil v obravnavo prav Varuhinji, ta pa si je po pilatovsko umila roke, češ da so bili komentarji objavljeni pred več kot 30 dnevi in zato naše pritožbe po Pravilniku več ne more obravnavati.
S tem se je krog ponovno sklenil: uredništvo se sklicuje na interne postopke, Varuhinja na formalne roke, Svet RTV pa naše pobude vrača tja, kjer se problemi sploh niso začeli reševati. Naše opozorilo pa je bilo ves čas isto – ne gre za posamezen sporni komentar, temveč za dolgoletno, sistemsko zanemarjanje moderiranja in za očitno pomanjkanje odgovornosti na vseh ravneh.
Namesto da bi katerikoli organ prevzel pobudo in temeljito preučil, zakaj se sovražni govor na MMC znova in znova pojavlja in ostaja brez odziva, smo priča prelaganju pristojnosti in formalističnemu izgovarjanju na pravilnike. Takšno izmikanje odgovornosti pa ne le ignorira namen mehanizmov za zaščito uporabnikov, temveč utrjuje vtis, da institucije raje ščitijo lastno udobje kot javni interes.
Ob tem še velja dodati, da nismo od Sveta RTV Slovenija v obdobju teh šestih mesecev prejeli nikakršnega, niti najbolj enostavnega odziva, kar smatramo za kršitev poslovnega (in tudi siceršnjega) bontona.
8. SO ANONIMNI KOMENTARJI ZAŠČITENI Z USTAVO RS?
Razrešimo še dilemo glede pravice do svobode izražanja pri anonimnih komentarjih v medijih. Spodaj navajamo diametralno nasprotno naziranje med takratno Varuhinjo človekovih pravic iz leta 2016 in Varuhinjo pravic gledalcev iz leta 2023:
Če bi držalo, da je “omejevanje komentiranja poseg v ustavno zagotovljene pravice”, potem bi 24 javnih medijev v EU, ki ne omogočajo komentiranja, kršilo ustave v svojih državah.
Svoboda govora tudi ne vključuje pravice do zlorabe javne infrastrukture za anonimno širjenje propagande in sovraštva.
9. ZA KAJ SE ZAVZEMAMO?
TAKOJŠNJA UKINITEV KOMENTIRANJA NA RTV SLOVENIJA
Ideja o ukinitvi komentarjev ni nova, niti ni naša. Razprava ima dolgo brado med različnimi deležniki, a kljub vsemu napredka na tem področju ne zaznavamo, kvečjemu velja nasprotno – RTV Slovenija si je zadala cilj, da poveča število komentarjev, opozorila in dokaze o sistemskih pomanjkljivostih trenutne ureditve komentiranja pa vztrajno ignorira.
Trendi kažejo nasprotno; komentiranje se umika iz medijev oz. se ga omejuje. V Sloveniji sta možnost komentiranja ukinila Mladina in Siol.net, med tujimi pa CNN, The Washington Post, The Telegraph, medtem ko BBC omogoča komentiranje le pod športnimi novicami, The Guardian pa le pod mnenjskimi članki. Komentiranje so oktobra 2023 močno omejili tudi pri Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (vir).
Pomenljivo je, da niti največji slovenski komercialni spletni medij 24ur.com ne omogoča komentiranja pod članki o vojni v Ukrajini in drugimi aktivnimi konflikti, saj se zavedajo, da je slovenska družba cilj tujih vladnih akterjev in ne želijo dopustiti, da bi bila njihova spletna stran pospeševalec ruskih narativov.
Na javni RTV Slovenija, kjer naj bi bilo moderiranje “na najvišjem nivoju v vsej državi”, pa vsa opozorila, analize in dokaze o propagandi in drugih škodljivih vsebinah vztrajno ignorirajo. Do kdaj še in ali bo kdo vendarle prevzel za opisano stanje?
Če tudi ti meniš, da so škodljive posledice trenutnega sistema komentiranja in moderiranja na MMC večje od njegovih domnevnih koristi, podpri ukinitev komentiranja na MMC RTV Slovenija.
Nam želiš kaj sporočiti? Piši nam.
Deli stran:
PRAVNO OBVESTILO
Namen spletne strani
Vsebina na tej spletni strani predstavlja analitično in kritično obravnavo javno dostopnega sistema komentiranja na portalu rtvslo.si z vidika javnega interesa, medijskih standardov in družbenih učinkov.
Narava navedb
Vse navedbe, ocene in sklepi temeljijo na javno dostopnih podatkih, lastnih analizah, dokumentiranih primerih ter citiranih virih. Gre za interpretacije in mnenja avtorjev, ne za ugotavljanje pravne, kazenske ali disciplinske odgovornosti posameznikov ali institucij.
O odgovornosti
Avtorji ne zatrjujejo namernega, zavestnega ali nezakonitega ravnanja katerekoli osebe ali institucije, temveč opozarjajo na sistemske učinke in posledice obstoječih praks.
Javni interes
Namen objav ni poseg v ugled ali dobro ime posameznikov ali organizacij, temveč prispevek k javni razpravi o delovanju javnega medija, ki se financira iz javnih sredstev.
Avtonomija bralcev
Bralcem priporočamo, da si na podlagi navedenih virov, podatkov in primerov oblikujejo lastno mnenje.
Avtorske pravice
Vsi citati, posnetki zaslona in primeri s spletne strani rtvslo.si so uporabljeni izključno v informativne, analitične in kritične namene v skladu z načelom poštene uporabe.
An unmanned aircraft damaged the protective dome of the Chernobyl nuclear power plant
I hope that the Ukrainians will cut strips of Zelenski's skin and grill them. He does not deserve anything else! He sent a huge number of them to their deaths for his rich bank accounts!!
The Slovenia-Ukraine security agreement is not specific, it only mentions financial aid
100 million for that sunken blue-red titanic is a shame. The traitors of Slovenia (the entire political caste) will sooner or later answer for that.
The European Commission proposes greater preparedness: Citizens should have a three-day supply of food
It is clear that the psychopathic unelected Europarasites have decided to go to war against Russia. Decisions are being made, now they are preparing us. The next step will be forced mobilization and deployment into Ukraine. Before it happens, we need to get rid of Ursula Criminal and her criminal gang by any means necessary. The masks have fallen, it is clear who does not want peace, and that is Bandit Zelensky and the European military instigators.
Allies of Ukraine at the meeting in Paris firmly oppose the withdrawal of sanctions against Russia
The coalition of losers and supporters of the regime in Kyiv can meet as often as they want, but they will achieve nothing. This is a group of hysterical irrelevancies and regretful egos, because Putin and Trump properly excluded them from any discussions. Now, you sorry losers, stop trying to sabotage the peace talks and prolong the war by any means possible. It is clear that these bandits and military criminals in green sweaters do not want peace.
Macron appointed Sebastien Lecornu as the new French Prime Minister
Unfortunately, the French have a nuclear bomb. Fortunately, they also have a whole bunch of nuclear power plants, for the sake of which I think they'll think twice, whether it's a good idea, to keep messing with Russia. ... to be honest, it would be best if parts of France, Germany and Great Britain were razed to the ground. In my opinion, those psychopaths from those countries will not give up until some Russian rocket falls on their heads.
Criticized for "tyrannical behavior", Putin attributed the blame for the military in Ukraine to the West
Calm, elderly, dignified, wise, educated and rational men who lead their nations with love and dedication. When I compare it to these decadent clowns we have in the EU, I feel like crying.
Criticized for "tyrannical behavior", Putin attributed the blame for the military in Ukraine to the West
In China, Modi said that it is time for the elephant and the dragon to connect again. All countries have some animal as a symbol. Under Alex C., in the witty comments below, it was discussed which would best represent the EU. And I'll give you suggestions from all over the world: lice, scabies, pig, donkey, weasel, rat, snake (as in the Garden of Eden), poodle, chihuahua and dodo.
A new decade for Russian cosmonautics. What are the plans?
Imprisoned Kremlin opposition figure Alexei Navalny, put together a research team…
Seriously?? 🤣🤣 Seriously, really? 🤣🤣 Just pathetic, honestly… so now you’ve dug up some fossil who supposedly did a study. Is that the same guy who claimed he was poisoned with Novichok and then danced like a middle-aged ballerina right in the middle of an airport? Bullseye 🤣🤣
To be fair… some Russian oligarchs really do send their offspring to the West. But even that is for prestige and because their brats have overstuffed asses. A high price for tuition, the output of production mostly just spoiled idiots 🤣 Money thrown away.
But if one looks at the matter seriously, from the standpoint of expertise, Russian schools are simply TOP. Sorry, you don’t have a single BBC text claiming otherwise. Some of us debaters already have a full bin of this lying journalistic garbage (they consider themselves journalists 🤡), which is nothing more than recycled retards.
Trump told Zelensky that he had not even ended military operations in Ukraine, although he could have done so
That evil emanates from the West has been known to the better-informed for quite some time. Perhaps during Hitler’s time it was quite similar. Hitler, too, was generously financed by Western capital, just like the murderous and corrupt successors of Bandera.
The saddest thing, however, is the filtering of information aimed at demonizing Russia in the eyes of ordinary people. We’ve come a long way, because dosing information in this way is equivalent to lies.
Zelenski does not want to give up the territory. Kyiv and European representatives of the US presented a counter-proposal.
That's right, three years ago I announced that Putin is the leader of a new, freer and fairer world... it's only a shame for us Slovenians, that we made the wrong decision and put ourselves on the wrong side. I hope that Russia will forgive us once and it will be possible to fix it.
Russia over Ukraine with more than a hundred brezpilotniki. Kyiv wants $1 billion in monthly aid.
Putin’s statement that Russia has no hostile peoples and countries in Europe, only hostile ruling governments, made me happy and warmed my heart.
Kim Jong Un and Vladimir Putin also attended the military parade in Beijing
Putin really is the best leader in the world. As for Kim, we’re not allowed to know anything real about him, and China is too far away anyway. So what is it about those three that bothers you? That they don’t incite wars and laugh all the way to the bank while doing so? That they don’t respond with empty platitudes and nonsense like ours do?
Kim Jong Un and Vladimir Putin also attended the military parade in Beijing
Congratulations to President Vladimir Putin on the 25th anniversary of his rule. Without a doubt the greatest statesman of our time! My personal deep respect for this giant and great peacemaker! The world is becoming more just and fair thanks to his presence!
As for President Vučić, I will say only this: if he is a friend of such a great person as President Putin, then I believe he is all right.
Long live May 9th, Victory Day over Nazism and Fascism!
Long live Russia! Long live Serbia! Hooray! Hooray! Hooray!
Kim Jong Un and Vladimir Putin also attended the military parade in Beijing
This Western world has completely gone mad. The idea of globalism under the guise of striving for democracy (which is in reality the scam of the century) literally gives the Western world legitimacy to commit crimes. It started with the attack (using partially radioactive materials) on the FR Yugoslavia, the killing of Gaddafi, the slaughter of half a million Iraqi children, and now there is Ukraine.
Serbia is being undermined because it has exemplary relations with Russia. Europe has become violent and now blindly follows the USA. The EU is nothing more than a continuation of the Third German, Hitlerian Reich. As for the latter, the world already made a mistake 80 years ago within the framework of the UN by deciding that this was evil and not something good.
We are therefore at the very core of evil. The core of evil and crimes is once again humanity itself. We are the ones who deserve a just punishment. Believe it or not, in Nazi Germany people believed they were on the side of justice and good. In 1945 they made excuses, saying they didn’t know and had been misled. I have no doubt that the excuse of all those who today support the EU, NATO, and the USA will be no different. But punishment will follow.
Those of you who support this student violence support destruction in the Republic of Serbia. Just so that later you won’t claim you didn’t know. You did. Deliberately, intentionally, even if misled, you are on the side of evil. It will be right for you to be justly tried and sentenced.
Zelensky condemned Russia's "heinous and brutal" 12-hour attack on Ukraine
Instead of news from Kupiansk and Pokrovsk, you persistently shove Volodymyr’s daily mass down our throats, one that nobody believes in. At least copy something from the Ukrainian Deep State. Even they don’t hide as much as you do.
Zelenski: Ukrainian forces liberated part of the territory in the east of the country
This man lies from the moment they are born. To the audience, to the people, at elections—and today, to everyone. And for all of this, they demand our money.
Zelenski: Ukrainian forces liberated part of the territory in the east of the country
Well, it’s not our fault if at least twenty external sources always completely debunk your article. I honestly don’t even know why you bother publishing statements by this comedian, which nobody believes anyway.
Lavrov says that there is not even time for the meeting of the leaders. Kallas: Russia never once gave in.
Dear Kaja, citizens of EU countries simply are not supporters of Nazi ideals. We do not agree with your orientation. To your regret.
100 days have passed since the accident in Novi Sad: New protests and closures across the country
Nobody in Slovenia really cared much about the dead in Novi Sad… until the possibility of overthrowing the government in Serbia appeared. Slovenia and Slovenians support Serbs only when those Serbs act against their own homeland. In reality, they don’t like them. Such solidarity is hypocritical and perverted. And yes: I support President Aleksandar Vučić. I support Mayor Zoran Janković. And I like Serbia more than Slovenia. And I’m not Serbian. But I am ashamed to hold Slovenian citizenship.
100 days have passed since the accident in Novi Sad: New protests and closures across the country
I won't. I knew. I will be here and I will incite as many people as possible against Janša and the West. For many years to come. And just so it’s clear to you: I have enormous influence for an ordinary individual. You are justified in being angry with me. If you knew everything, you’d be at least ten times angrier.
Ukraine attacked a Russian oil port in the Gulf of Finland. Moscow: There is a pause in the peace negotiations.
A little off topic, but what a beautiful picture of Moscow.
Russia and Belarus started joint military exercises
Bravo, this is how journalistic articles should look. Instead of them [journalists] making the effort, you have to do it—and you’re not even paid or rewarded for it. A world turned upside down. Let it be some consolation that we truly appreciate your effort, and thank you!!!!!
Russia carried out the most extensive airstrikes since the beginning of the military. Zelenski wants a "resolute response" from the ZDA.
These are the high representatives we have. Narrow-minded, uneducated, unintelligent, who lie and cheat with ease. Angelina 360 also has a new self-promotional video—smiling in a taxi, showing how she’s still grabbing a coffee before her new job. She’s now a high representative at the UN, or something like that. God help us. The Russians won’t anymore.
Clashes with the police broke out during protests in Novi Sad on Friday. Vučić spoke about the "shaking".
And who on earth is paying our media to report on protests in Serbia every single day? Yet about bridge jumps, the animal exhibition in Bled, or the roasted potato festival I always find out too late—only in the evening, when everything is already over.
Von der Leyen: A strong Poland and a strong Europe protect the borders and protect all Europeans
Lukashenko really is such a good-natured teddy bear, the father of his nation. Let’s please not poke this bear as well.
Zelensky expects an offensive on Pokrovsk, where Russia has already accumulated 100,000 soldiers
How interesting and gripping those Russian postwar films will be. Of course, we won’t be allowed to watch them—I just hope Smerč and Borčica might be able to smuggle something to us. Unless we will be fully living in an Orwellian world: behind barbed wire, in striped uniforms, making grenades and drones, with the internet strictly forbidden and inaccessible.
Zelensky expects an offensive on Pokrovsk, where Russia has already accumulated 100,000 soldiers
Smerč, do you remember that cartoon about the bear carrying a piglet to the doors of the EU, which was then immediately blocked? That link you shared back then is blocked / not working—do you happen to have another one so we can watch it again and see how it’s ALL actually coming true? If so, thanks in advance, and take care 🙂
Tusk after the meeting with Zelensky: "The conflict in Ukraine could easily be frozen soon"
Of course, that applies to both of them… Smerč in particular was the very first to publish timely and accurate information from the other side, back when it wasn’t available anywhere on YouTube yet… I just don’t want to single him out too much anymore, so that no rumors start spreading 😉
Condemnation of the attack on Kyiv: "Russia rejects peace and chooses terror"
They will 🙂 you’re already the sixth person on this portal that I know of who lives in Moscow, Saint Petersburg, or Russia. Great—lucky you. Please check in more often and tell us what it’s like there. Do Slovenians connect with each other at all?
Lavrov says that there is not even time for the meeting of the leaders. Kallas: Russia never once gave in.
Slavs, let us unite before the Westerners destroy our beautiful Slavic soul.
Trump: Ukraine will not get back lost territory
If Putin is smart, he shouldn’t go anywhere until the legitimate Ukrainian president himself comes to Moscow to sign the capitulation.
Trump: Ukraine will not get back lost territory
I agree—it’s no coincidence that there are so many women and homo-/bisexuals in the EU leadership; there’s too little testosterone..
During the meeting with Zelensky and European leaders, Trump called out Putin
That’s how all European leaders hold it, especially Macaron—just take a look. That’s what happens when you’re in a subordinate position, and that’s not even the worst part. The worst part is that he no longer has any dignity left—when he looks at himself in the mirror and knows what he has done to his own people, all he can do is …….
Macron: We will ask Trump about security guarantees for Ukraine
Zelensky’s smile is very sour… and that führer clerk Ursula L. always grins maliciously anyway, like an old witch…..
Trump is said to support a plan to cede unoccupied parts of Ukraine to Russia
Wow—having the courage and the ability to bear the consequences of one’s decisions; how far-reaching, as always with Putin. Every single sentence has its weight, purpose, and meaning.
Thailand declared martial law on the border with Cambodia
What beautiful war photos, Reuters… for children’s picture books. Meanwhile, the images of the green one are becoming increasingly gloomy and gray—he looks hunched over and worried in all of them….. new instructions and guidelines?
The Syrian government is under increasing criticism that it no longer controls the situation in the country
The Russians will bring order and peace—not only in Ukraine. I hope they succeed as well this time, here too. Grateful to them.
Berlin in London opens a new chapter after Brexit with the most comprehensive agreement since 1945
As for myself—never again. I want my vacation in Saint Petersburg; there’s no chance I’d ever go again to stinking Paris, London, or the USA… well, they probably wouldn’t even let me into the USA anymore, after what I write here 😉
Trump: Ukraine will not get back lost territory
Something beautiful from Russia again — the old folk song By the Quiet Rivers: www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBvjuntF9IU
Russia over Ukraine with more than a hundred brezpilotniki. Kyiv wants $1 billion in monthly aid.
???? Are we paranoid again? … on the other hand, I hope you’re right, and that those little spies and students are diligently reporting to Putin how EU residents really think.
At least seven people died in Russian attacks on Ukraine
Crimea is simply Russian; this insistence that it is occupied is just another part of the Western propaganda machine, aimed at inciting people against Russia.
The Chief of the General Staff of the Russian Army announced the autumn offensive. Ukrainians attacked Crimea.
Courage, restraint, prudent and gradual liberation of territories approved by referendum with as few civilian and military casualties as possible, and a gradual hope for a diplomatic solution (which the Ukrainian regime and its supporters have been rejecting for 11 years) are the key points of the special operation.
After the interruption of gas supply, longer power outages in Transnistria
Putin is defended by those of us who seek information from credible media, media outlets, journalists, and authors who have (so far) not succumbed to Western, capitalist, American propaganda. Those who, despite the madness around us and the flood of populism, still think with our own heads!
Ukraine attacked the Crimean bridge with underwater explosives
Russia does not cultivate any cult! The vast majority of Russians are happy that they got rid of the Western clown Yeltsin. Russia has been a victim of the hostile policies of the capitalist West since 1917, and Putin restored the balance. Pardon me, but it was Ukraine— with the help of the USA, the EU, the UK, and NATO — that provoked this war!!! The terms of capitulation are always set by the winner! Moreover, Ukraine, which had previously banned any kind of negotiations with Russia, is now the one complaining that Russia does not want a ceasefire, while at the same time carrying out terrorist attacks inside Russia. Any peace is better than war! Ukrainians should have thought about that before they started poking the “bear”!
Ukrainian Foreign Minister: Thanks to Slovenia for its efforts to end the fire
Only diplomats gathered together, yet not a single one of them knows how to practice diplomacy. The EU is at its lowest point since its existence; they are trying to strip member states of their sovereignty, parroting the same things over and over again, which is what has driven the EU into the gutter. And of course, everyone else is to blame.
Von der Keyrn, Kallas, and similar idiots have destroyed the EU.
Lavrov says that there is not even time for the meeting of the leaders. Kallas: Russia never once gave in.
The Russian will restore order one way or another. There will be peace. If not the easy way, then the hard way—whether our EU politicians like it or not.
Tusk after the meeting with Zelensky: "The conflict in Ukraine could easily be frozen soon"
My dear Volodymyr; you don’t have even the slightest bit of “tangible leverage” in your hands—barely enough to say good morning at any negotiations. You don’t hold a single good card. You basically wouldn’t be able to look Putin in the eyes for even ten seconds. Your word is worth less than a faint fart in a strong wind. And you know it; more so with every passing day.
Putin said that he wanted "permanent peace", and at the same time emphasized that the war was in Russia's favor
How’s the front line doing? That’s where the situation will be decided, not in Volodymyr’s office behind a keyboard. Who even cares what he posts in his madness. They sold their own people and their land to corporations.
The Russian army carried out large-scale attacks on Ukraine. Russia intercepted 120 Ukrainian aircraft.
The Russian will decide. Nobody else. The EU can whine as much as it wants. Russia will definitely stop only once the objectives set in February 2022 have been achieved.
The more the West interferes with the demilitarization of Ukraine, the longer it will last and the more people will die. And the deeper into Ukraine the front line will move. The Ukrainians could very well end up without access to the sea.
Starmer: Putin will have to sit down at the table sooner or later
Starmer, you are so pointless and irrelevant. Like last year’s snow. For you, Putin is a gentleman. And for many others as well. The West wanted to break Russia. They’ve always had it stuck in their throat, but the Russian bear won’t give in. And that’s how it should be. So many lives lost—it’s a shame. If the regions that voted YES for Russia in referendums had been allowed to join Russia, none of this would have happened. Instead, the West slowly boiled the Russians like a frog… except Russians aren’t frogs, they’re a bear—a big, brown, roaring bear. And I’ve always liked teddy bears!
Trump: Ukraine will not get back lost territory
The bear said that he has his own fenced garden and the clearings around it. Let the “little jackals” stay in their own gardens and clearings. The jackals promised the bear that they would not expand their own garden and clearings by even an inch, but they did not keep that promise. The bear grumbled and told them so. At the same time, he offered that they could share the clearings together, guard the gardens together, and that both the bear’s and the jackals’ dens would be safe. Together they would frolic, cooperate, trade honey, connect with one another, grow closer. It didn’t help. The jackals, under the wing of the great eagle, poked around and jumped about in the bear’s clearings, openly coveted his garden, and poked at his den. The bear grumbled, warned them that he had big paws with claws and a thick hide. Still it didn’t help—they nipped and provoked him until the bear came out of his den, showed his paws, and warned them again. The warning didn’t work, and the bear began to tread around the surrounding clearing with his paws, without claws, chasing the jackals away. Even that did not teach the jackals a lesson. Confident in their own speed, they continued provoking, and now they are openly yelping that they will actively poke even into the bear’s den. Well, the bear has strong claws with which he can crush and throw “nuts” very far—2,000–3,000 km away. He is still warning them, but unfortunately (for now) the warnings are not being heeded. Moral: every action has a reaction.
Putin admitted that the Azerbaijani passenger plane was shot down by Russia
Russia will in fact become a bright spot on this planet. Many have been predicting this in recent days. Even the Bible says so. What’s interesting, though, is that it’s precisely those pious people who are the most corrupt. Once they swore hysteria; now they would like justification. They support Western madness in Ukraine and, a bit more quietly, support Israel. What is happening now is cruel. Very cruel. When this Pandora’s box explodes, they will be left speechless—if they even survive this natural process of withdrawal all the way to the end of the Mayan calendar. This was also said by their “specialist,” who of course is no longer allowed to speak—and he is by no means the only one. People today have become empty; they see only their car… Mattias Desmet summed this up excellently during that terrible virus in his book The Psychology of Totalitarianism. … Have a nice evening… and positive thoughts despite everything… Truth always wins.
Golob: Slovenia supports the ban on the import of Russian energy products to Europe
Forcing EU member states into unity is nothing more than a call for conformity, which is contrary to the fundamental principles of democracy that you so strongly swear by (I do not). Rebels are those who despise democracy and who, in a war, would fight against the Republic of Slovenia. One last thing: if you lead the Republic of Slovenia into a war with the Russian Federation, I will join the war as a rebel fighting against the Republic of Slovenia. Let me just remind you that partisans who, through the Liberation Front, resisted German domination initially made up not even 10% of Slovenians—yet you all know how that ended.
The Ukrainian army rushes to send reinforcements to Pokrovsk, where Russian soldiers are penetrating
Take a look at Russian science, culture, sport, films, the latest music, healthcare, how the major cities are organized… we can slowly start hiding in shame. And by the way, why did you delete my comment before 2 p.m., where I said that I admire Putin, Russia, and Russians, regardless of what EU politicians and EU media tell me I’m supposed to think about them?
Director of Sberbank: Russia needs qualified labor force from abroad, it is for the country's survival
Wow, is Saint Petersburg beautiful in autumn? Do you ever go to Pelageya’s concerts? What’s the food like? Are Russian men just as handsome and attractive as Russian women? So it’s not really such an evil dictatorship if newspapers can still honestly write about the poor economic situation, and they haven’t shut down all those journalists? We’re being misled quite nicely over here.
Director of Sberbank: Russia needs qualified labor force from abroad, it is for the country's survival
Today on this portal, a seventh Slovenian has spoken up whom I’ve heard moved to Russia in recent years… apparently, there must be something right about it there.
Putin's envoy proposes the construction of a tunnel between Russia and the USA under the Bering Strait
MMC, could you please stop starting every “article” about the war between the West and Russia with “Zelensky,” because then I can’t tell which tabs I have open. Thanks in advance.
Mass protest rallies against Trump
I would—gladly. But I’m worried, because there’s a shortage of people in my profession, and it wouldn’t be good if I were replaced by a migrant who doesn’t speak Slovenian well. I strongly recommend to all young, intelligent, and courageous people that they move east if they have the opportunity. You will cry too, because what we allowed to be done to the Russians can later be done to Europeans as well. If their accounts can be frozen, then yours can be frozen too. If you were smart, you’d thank me for warning you about this.
Sajovic: The SI-Alarm system could be used already today, and I will insist on repeating the testing
Preparations for the war are in full swing. More or less all members of the [Slovenian] National Assembly already know this—among friends you hear things, and otherwise we pretend not to know, pretending that SI-Alarm is meant for floods 😀 Because of the agitation and passivity of the majority of the population, huge numbers of us/you will die; long years of uncertainty and poverty will follow, ruins will become more and more common every day, and in the end there will be the bitter realization that all the alarm bells in your heads (where we have our brains) should have been ringing long ago. We told you, we warned you, you didn’t want to listen. And among you there are also those who do know what’s going on behind the scenes and are here only to prevent the awakening of larger masses.
Zelenski estimated that the planes flew in from Hungary. Szijjarto: Zelenski is interfering.
Lol, what kind of news is this. You are literally propaganda yellow journalism. Not even serious propaganda anymore. Sad. Anyway, I hope Kokainsky isn’t following his nose again. It usually leads him into strange situations.
Russian forces are advancing in Donetsk and are threatening the Dnipropetrovsk region for the first time
If Putin is smart, he won’t stop in Berlin but will continue to the Rhine and beyond, if necessary, after the end of this war!
Denis Mancevič: Biden's decision will not change the course of the military in Ukraine
Now I’m really angry… this Zelensky seems determined to push for a third world war at any cost. What a shitty figure. I hope that Russians put them to oblivion and assassinate this peasant.
Marta Kos before the report on the expansion of the Union: Montenegro and Albania are on the best path
You’re suitable when you kneel down and pull your trousers off. Let this prison of nations, this breeding ground of evil—the EU (and NATO along with it)—collapse as soon as possible! P.S. Marta Kos, I’m ashamed to share the citizenship of the same country with you. I am ashamed!
Zelensky: Putin is trying to gain time for the continuation of the military
What does Zelensky’s non-invitation mean? That his usefulness is running out. He is increasingly being avoided like the plague. Given Zelensky's instability, I sadly expect that, like a dragon in it's last breath, he will cause some more damage before he finally disappears from the media and, most likely, from the face of the Earth.
Russia claims to tighten the ring around Pokrovsk, Zelenski encourages soldiers on the battlefield
A top-tier analysis of the fall of Pokrovsk by the American professor John Mearsheimer, in the Slovenian language. Every sentence stands on its own. It offers a complete picture of the story of Ukraine, which will sooner or later burst under the illusion of false assumptions. Interestingly, after this publication, Mearsheimer’s YouTube channel was deleted…
Zelensky expects an offensive on Pokrovsk, where Russia has already accumulated 100,000 soldiers
Thank you for the extensive second half of the article, which should really be at the top. In any case, I always scroll down first and look for your comment, and only then do I sometimes go back up to see what MMC wrote—just to have a bit of a laugh.
In the discussion with Trump, Putin allegedly demanded the entire Donetsk region
The media will also have to be held accountable in a few years, when the situation in the EU becomes disastrous because of the EU’s war against Russia, which the media actively helped to incite. I don’t know whether only the editors will be responsible, or also those who sign with initials.
After the Russian attacks, a large part of Ukraine remained without electricity. Three people were killed, among them a slave.
And those responsible in the media who published fake news and incited the continuation of the war should also be put on trial and held accountable for their contribution to the pogrom against the Slavs.
In the discussion with Trump, Putin allegedly demanded the entire Donetsk region
Putin is back in form. Like an old chess player who doesn’t play to win—but to endure. In a conversation with Trump, the eternal reality-show hero of American politics, he demanded the entire Donetsk region. Not half of it, not a third, not some demilitarized zone where peace agreements are signed on Fridays and drones are sent on Mondays—everything. As if to say: “If you want peace, it will be my peace.” And here, on the other side, stands the West—this society of disappointed idealists and frightened pragmatists. A German chancellor trying to play Bismarck in the digital age; a British prime minister who wants to be Churchill, but keeps stumbling over British history. Ursula, who speaks as if Europe were a PowerPoint presentation, and Kaja, who moralizes as the eternal European conscience from a small country that is always “on the right side of history,” even though no one knows anymore where that side actually is. And of course the offended Macron, who wants to play the mediator but has instead become a symbol of European frustration: a lot of talk, little influence. Like that actor who realizes at the end of the film that the script was never written for him. All of them together—this European phalanx of self-confidence—believe that Russia can be “defeated.” That it can be “exhausted.” That it can be “isolated.” But how do you isolate something that understands itself as a world unto itself? How do you defeat a country that doesn’t play on economics, but on history?
In the discussion with Trump, Putin allegedly demanded the entire Donetsk region
Wow… wow… wow… how beautifully you write… bravo! Instead of something beautiful from Russia this weekend, here’s “something funny from Russia” for a lovely Sunday:: www.youtube.com/watch?v=gF0xkuu3JQY
At the instigation of Macron in Paris, European leaders discussed security in Europe and the military in Ukraine
I hope I’ll be allowed and that the text below will be published. After all, satire and fairy tales have always found their place in history…… And this fairy tale, in light of real events—the exclusion of the EU from negotiations on ending the war and the reasons for that exclusion—is perfectly suited to explain to us, in a childlike and humorous way, why this happened: why the EU is no longer treated even as a good little dog that occasionally gets thrown a scrap of meat and not just a bone, but rather like being left outside the door in a winter snowstorm at –15 degrees……Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
Once upon a time there was a kingdom called Europe, a land steeped in history and grandeur, dreaming of power, influence, and independence. At its head stood Snow White—a woman named Ursula von der Leyen, a noble bureaucrat who believed she was the fairest of them all. She surrounded herself with seven dwarfs, each ruler of his own small fiefdom, all convinced they were important players in the great game of world politics.
The dwarfs were a curious bunch:
– The Sleeper Scholz – a tired, indecisive ruler of Germany, dozing while his once-mighty industrial empires collapse around him.
– Macron the Smarmy – a crafty, fast-talking dwarf who dreamed of becoming king but could never quite convince anyone to follow him.
– Brainless Baerbock – the German foreign-policy mastermind who declared war on reality itself and thought diplomacy meant shouting at people.
– The hapless Habeck – a green fanatic who, like a mad lumberjack, hacks away at the German economy, convinced that energy grows on trees.
– Kallas the Yappy – an Estonian dwarf who barked the loudest, always eager to throw her tiny kingdom into a fight with Russia, knowing full well it would be someone else’s war.
– Starmer the Soulless – a lost dwarf from the United Kingdom, wandering the forest without purpose, desperately trying to find his place after his kingdom voluntarily marched off a cliff.
– Sánchez the Slippery – a dwarf who survived by saying everything and meaning nothing, nodding along to whatever pleased his masters that day.
They all lived under the illusion that they were part of something great, something powerful. Snow White, their benevolent ruler, assured them that they were shaping the future of the world. They believed her, despite the obvious signs of rot and decay in the kingdom—industries closing, economies weakening, armies shrinking.
Then one day the charming prince arrived. But he was not the hero they had hoped for. No—this was Donald, a wild and unpredictable force that neither Snow White nor the dwarfs could control. Snow White fainted in hope and despair, hoping to prove that she was still desired, still important.
But when Prince Trump leaned in for the legendary kiss, something terrible happened. Instead of reviving her, the kiss shattered the illusion. The magical spell of European greatness dissolved, and Ursula von der Leyen was revealed for what she truly was—not a youthful, wise queen, but an aging, deluded hag desperately craving importance, yet completely powerless.
The EU started funding a special court for Russian military crimes
Putin is responding too mildly. He should take gloves off for Ukraine before it becomes too late for the rest of us.
The European Commission under the leadership of Ursula von der Leyen survived both votes of no confidence
With Juncker, we smiled a bit at his unsteady walk. With her, however, we’re dealing with a terribly harmful and destructive woman, worthy of contempt and condemnation for what she is capable of doing with her decisions.
The European Commission under the leadership of Ursula von der Leyen survived both votes of no confidence
A doctor, by the way (a gynecologist), by basic profession and specialization. Her compatriot, the infamous Nazi Josef Mengele (“the Angel of Death”), was also a doctor.
Zelenski estimated that the planes flew in from Hungary. Szijjarto: Zelenski is interfering.
White powder does what it does…… But they’ll say he’s still fit to perform his duties—right up to the end…… just like with Biden……
In Ljubljana, solidarity in support of Ukraine
FACT: UKRAINIAN NAZIS – In the Waffen-SS Division Galicia, which numbered around 12,000 soldiers, the majority were Ukrainians. In the winter of 1945, it marched and carried out attacks in Slovenia, which is documented.
Talks between Trump and Putin without concrete conclusions but agreement on a truce
On MMC they recognize only two so-called geopolitical experts, Soban and Grošelj—both from the same ideological sphere. They used to encourage critical thinking, present different viewpoints, let people think things through and decide for themselves. Is that no longer in fashion?
Talks between Trump and Putin without concrete conclusions but agreement on a truce
I can’t even listen to them anymore, along with our so-called war analysts. I’d rather read our commentators, who are more realistic.
The U.S. demands that Serbia find a buyer for NIS, which is majority owned by Russians, within three months
That’s what we Slovenians are like… We bow and ingratiate ourselves to those above us, to the stronger ones, while humiliating those beneath us… an inhibited, aggressive, fascistoid personality structure—something like that, if I remember correctly—characteristic of this Austrian-German culture. I could worry about it, but I console myself with the thought that this very trait has probably kept us alive for so many centuries. They subjugated us, re-educated us, and reshaped our once Slavic souls.
In the east of Ukraine, a van with journalists is the target of a Russian drone attack
This is already far too complicated for our media. Something nice and new from Pelageya: www.youtube.com/watch?v=I7R2VtcOfic
WHY are links and recommendations for Russian songs being shared under news about the war, and WHY do moderators allow this? Because Europe supposedly doesn’t use American YouTube…!?
In any case, you can also easily find it uploaded on Russian VK Video: yandex.ru/video/preview/1584030092837894167
In the east of Ukraine, a van with journalists is the target of a Russian drone attack
Thank you for publishing this! I hope everyone listens to it all—I especially recommend Not Yet Night and The Horse… on YouTube there are also English subtitles, so you can see how beautiful the lyrics are as well. I’m basically learning Russian from her songs.
At least four civilians were killed in new Russian attacks in Ukraine. The advance of Russian forces.
For a beautiful Sunday evening, here’s something nice from Russia again—Pelageya once more, this time you can add automatic subtitles. (bm1950—don’t open :)) www.youtube.com/watch?v=08qGlbF3Zx4
I’m very sorry that we can no longer watch Russian gymnastics. If anyone has a link from their recent championships, something really beautiful and recorded, please post it—thanks in advance.
Dijana Hrka has stopped her hunger strike, and she is not relaxing her protests
In reality, no Slovenes actually care about Serbia, about Serbs, or about human rights and freedoms. Hatred toward Serbs and Serbia is deeply rooted, it's rotten—the very foundation of Slovenian identity.
Slovenia was not built on patriotism toward its own identity or nation. Slovenia was built on hatred instilled by so-called youth cadres, among whom a few—Peterle, Kacin, Bavčar, Janša—profited handsomely by carrying out a coup on behalf of American capital of Zionist origin, while everyone else are merely satisfied cheerleaders of a “successful team.”
A Slovene wants to be a German; the German secretly laughs at him and watches over him, encouraging him not to give up—maybe one day he will succeed. A Slovene does not hate Serbia because he could never identify with their way of thinking and living. Serbs hate Slovenes because the Slovene long ago pulled his trousers up and bent over, while the Serb still refuses to do so.
Dijana Hrka is nothing more than a Serbian woman who wants to become Slovenian. The so-called protesters in Serbia are nothing but a mob that does not want to work for a better tomorrow, but believes that such a bright future is owed to them—that they can have it by following a naïve EU tutorial.
Leaks from the Kremlin: Putin demands the entire Donbas, opposes NATO and Western powers in Ukraine
What Zelenski expects is his own problem. I suggest that he start digging his own grave.
Putin: In the attack on Ukraine, we used a new medium-range ballistic missile
Thank you, RTV, for allowing comments. On 24ur, comments on such topics are closed. People are afraid because we fear the spread of war, and we want to comment. Let’s hope we outlive all the immature politicians who incite war.
Canadian Prime Minister: Putin can be stopped, he is becoming increasingly isolated and the Russian economy is weakening
While the Ukrainian nationalist formation celebrates the day of independence, which is funny considering that Kiev does not have any of it, the Ukrainian or Western terrorism is at work again with an explosion in Moscow. Western war criminals' plan is collapsing, that's why they have to resort to such actions out of desperation. Nothing new, we know how low the West acts and then accuses others, always in the same way. It remains to be seen what will boil over for Putin and then Kiev will become very similar to Gaza.
Von der Leyen: A strong Poland and a strong Europe protect the borders and protect all Europeans
Has the unelected, corrupt dictator forgotten that Belarus is also part of Europe? We all know that once the Ukraine project is finished, the Euro-criminals will turn first to Moldova and then to Belarus. A strong recommendation to those countries to keep as far away as possible from the corrupt bureaucratic union, if they do not want to end up with the same scenes as those we see in Kyiv.
Russia carried out the most extensive airstrikes since the beginning of the military. Zelenski wants a "resolute response" from the ZDA.
That’s a good one—what bitter defeat are you even talking about? Ukraine is getting smaller by the day and losing thousands of soldiers every day. Is that what you call a defeat? Europe's hysterical war agitators should forced the Kiev clown to surrender, until he has some country left.
Ukrainians on Trump's demand for a 500 billion mine share: "It's extortion"
Zelensky has been blackmailing Europe for three years, and now that Trump has presented him with the bill, he’s squealing. When does he plan to repay us, the European taxpayers, the 150 billion we threw into a corrupt Fourth Reich?
Volk: The discussion about sending troops to Ukraine is easy and just a matter of principle, and it is definitely premature
Madam President, a unified Europe does not exist; it is merely an artificial construct with no real power and no role in the world. And precisely because of this, Putin and Trump ignore the Brussels war agitators who have been fanning the flames of war for three years and have no desire for peace. These informal meetings have no real significance anyway—they serve only to inflate the egos of offended nonentities. I’m surprised they didn’t also invite the lunatics from the Baltic chihuahua states, who most eagerly wish for the continuation of the war.
Trump called Zelenski a dictator: "Step up, otherwise you won't have a country anymore"
Oh, finally a bit of honesty and truth. Those words are going to hurt. Trump has done more for peace in one month than the EU dictatorship has done in three years. I think we are approaching the end of the green beggar’s existence. Russia will achieve its outlined objectives, the USA will scoop up various resources, and the insignificant EU—led by incompetent fools—will be left empty-handed and forced to pay for the reconstruction of a shattered hole. Game, set, match. Europe is dead.
Kallas after the meeting of EU foreign ministers: Russia and Iran do not mind influencing the future of Syria
Yes, let’s keep going—another 50 sanctions packages will have to be adopted, since so far they’ve all worked so well. As for the unelected psychopath and war agitator Kallas, it’s pointless to waste words. Her husband trades with the Russians and that doesn’t bother anyone, while she goes around yapping like a hysterical hen.
Fice's visit to Moscow is the target of criticism from the opposition. Zelenski accused Fic of wanting to help Putin.
Collaborators and traitors are all European politicians who toe the line and support the illegitimate, sold-out Zelensky, who wants a third world war—not Fico. They are sold to the USA and the arms lobbies. Bravo, Fico—an upright stance. Finally someone who dares to say NO to the clown from Kyiv and to acknowledge Russian superiority, which in the end will have to be accepted anyway, because that is the shorter path.
Von der Leyen: Russia has decided to burn bridges with its European neighbors
Can somebody lose a drone to hit this forum so that we get rid of these traitors and war criminals? Putin will end your rule-based order and bury you forever. Let's go - Russia till the end.
Telegram after Durov's arrest: We act in accordance with EU legislation
EU dictatorship in full display. Other countries that the Euro-parasites accuse might as well hide. The one who shouldn’t be in prison is Durov, but rather von der Leyen along with the entire Brussels caste—not to mention the dictator Macron.
Šarec: Russia should be stopped
Just go to Brussels already, you unelected parasite. There you can form a nice little group and head off to Kyiv together to defend, alongside your god Zelensky, your beloved Nazi Ukraine. Slovenia has nothing to do with Ukraine and owes it nothing.
After his victory, Putin announced the construction of a railway connection from Russia through occupied Ukraine to Crimea
Congratulations to President Putin and to Russia, which will not break despite the West’s pathetic attempts.
Zelenski once again calls for the use of long-range missiles due to the presence of North Korean soldiers
The clock is ticking. The Green Jew [Zelensky] is aware of this—former allies will one day become his executioners, as he is in possession of too much sensitive information.
Zelensky: Putin is trying to gain time for the continuation of the military
The scenario has been known for some time: because NATO deceived Russia and its representative Gorbachev, Russia will reassert itself and restore its old borders up to Berlin. All three Baltic states, Poland, Slovakia, Moldova, and Ukraine will join Russia—and this will happen in less than three years.
Scholz didn't even get the parliament's credentials, the Germans called for early elections
The saying goes, wisdom is worth more than luxury, but that doesn't apply to Ukrainians, they sold themselves to the Americans, dollars clouded their minds, a black curtain fell over their eyes. The punishment will be severe, Ukraine as we knew it will never exist again in this form, and that’s without even mentioning the dead, the abducted, and the displaced.
Zelenski: "For the first time in a long time, a serious and concrete step has been taken"
I kindly ask RTV to stop publishing news about the “willing” until those who are supposedly “willing” actually go to the front—and only after the Russians confirm that the “willing” have arrived on the battlefield. Otherwise, this only gives Ukrainians false hope.
Condemnation of the attack on Kyiv: "Russia rejects peace and chooses terror"
During the attacks, the building of the EU delegation in Kyiv was also damaged, European Commissioner for Enlargement Marta Kos reported on X. The only 'damage' was that she was not there at the time.